Seedhe content par jaiye
MutualFundAdvisor.in logo markMutualFundAdvisor.in
Abhi ki bhasha: Hinglish (Hindi in Roman script)
Passive Investing · Madhyam · 8 min read

Index Fund vs ETF: Asal Fark Kya Hai?

Chhota jawab

Index fund aur ETF (exchange-traded fund), dono ek jaisa market index track kar sakte hain, lekin inki structure alag hai. Index fund ek mutual fund hai: aap fund se seedhe units khareedte hain aur uske din ke end ke NAV par redeem karte hain. ETF ki units poore trading session mein stock exchange par market price par trade hoti hain, jo ETF ke apne underlying NAV se thodi alag ho sakti hai, aur ise khareedne ya bechne ke liye demat aur trading account chahiye, bilkul waise hi jaise share khareedne ke liye chahiye. Koi bhi structure apne-aap mein behtar nahi hai — ye alag-alag tareekon se invest karne ke liye suitable hain, aur dono market-linked investments bane rehte hain.

Amit Chadha · Mutual Fund Distributor · AMFI ARN: 349461 · Aakhri review

Index fund aur ETF, dono ek hi market index ko track karne ka lakshya rakh sakte hain, aur inhein bas alag naam wali ek hi cheez maan lena aasaan hai. Lekin structure mein, ye kaafi alag tarah se kaam karte hain — inhein aap kaise khareedte-bechte hain, inki price kaise tay hoti hai, aur ise rakhne ke liye kaun sa account chahiye, is maamle mein.

Ye article usi structural fark par focused hai, aur Academy ke 'index fund kya hai' wale article par based hai. Ye ye nahi batata ki koi ek structure har investor ke liye doosre se behtar hai — ye is par depend karta hai ki aap kaise invest karna chahte hain, is par nahi ki kaun sa product apne-aap mein behtar hai.

Dono Ek Jaisa Index Track Kar Sakte Hain

Index fund aur ETF, dono ko ek hi market index replicate karne ke liye banaya ja sakta hai, Academy ke index fund wale article mein bataye gaye usi broad tareeke ka istemal karte hue — underlying securities ko index ke apne weight ke kareeb proportion mein rakhkar. Passive, index-tracking objective wo cheez nahi hai jo in dono ko alag karti hai; fark isme hai ki har ek asal mein kaise khareeda, becha aur uski price tay ki jaati hai.

Index Fund Kaise Khareeda Aur Redeem Kiya Jaata Hai

Index fund ek mutual fund hai. Aap fund se seedhe, ya kisi distributor ke zariye, units khareedte hain aur us business day ke end mein calculate kiye gaye NAV par unhein fund ko wapas redeem karte hain — yahi NAV mechanism Academy ka NAV wala article kisi bhi open-ended scheme ke liye cover karta hai. Index fund mein SIP usi tarah kaam karta hai jaise kisi anya mutual fund category mein karta hai.

ETF Kaise Khareeda Aur Becha Jaata Hai

ETF ki units, ek baar banne ke baad, kisi stock exchange par listed hokar trade hoti hain, bilkul waise hi jaise kisi company ke shares hote hain. Aap exchange ke trading hours ke dauraan, us pal market jo bhi price de raha ho us par, kisi broker ke zariye ETF units khareedte aur bechte hain — na ki kisi ek din ke end ke NAV par. Isi wajah se, ETF rakhne ke liye demat account aur transaction ke liye trading account chahiye — wahi accounts jo share khareedne ke liye chahiye, ye baat Academy ka stock market wala article pehle hi ETF ke baare mein khaas taur par kehta hai.

Iska ye bhi matlab hai ki ETF ko usi trading din mein alag-alag prices par khareeda ya becha ja sakta hai, jaise koi share ho sakta hai, jabki index fund ki units us ek din ke akele NAV par hi khareedi ya redeem ki jaati hain, chaahe order din mein kisi bhi samay diya gaya ho.

Market Price vs NAV — Aur Dono Ke Beech Ka Antar

ETF ka bhi ek underlying NAV hota hai, jiski calculation usi tarah hoti hai jaise kisi mutual fund ki hoti hai, lekin exchange par aap jo price asal mein chukaate ya paate hain wo market price hai, jo ETF ki units trade karne wale buyers aur sellers se tay hoti hai — seedhe NAV se nahi. Ye dono figures aam taur par kareeb hote hain lekin bilkul ek jaise hone ka koi assurance nahi hai.

Jab market price NAV se zyada hota hai, to kaha jaata hai ki ETF premium par trade kar raha hai; jab ye kam hota hai, to discount par. Ye premium ya discount tab badh sakta hai jab kisi khaas ETF mein trading kam ho, ya market stress ke daur mein, aur ye index fund ke tracking difference se sach mein alag baat hai, bhale hi dono is baare mein hon ki kisi product ki price uski asli holdings ko kitni kareebi se darshaati hai.

Cost Aur Liquidity Se Judi Baatein

Expense ratio dono ke liye ek factor bana rehta hai, waise hi jaise Academy ka index fund wala article aur expense ratio wala article batate hain — kam cost apne-aap faisla karne wala factor nahi hai, lekin iski seedhe tulna karna zaroori hai. ETF khareedne ya bechne mein aam taur par brokerage aur, broker aur trade ke size par depend, exchange ka bid-ask spread bhi shaamil hota hai, jo index fund ki seedhi khareed mein usi tarah nahi aata.

ETF ki liquidity aanshik roop se is par depend karti hai ki wo khaas ETF exchange par kitni activity se trade hota hai — kam trade hone wale ETF mein bid-ask spread zyada chauda aur NAV se premium ya discount bada ho sakta hai, jise ye maan lene ke bajaay check kar lena chahiye ki ye har ETF mein ek jaisa hoga.

SIP Ke Liye Kaun Sa Suitable Hai

Index fund mein SIP usi tarah kaam karta hai jaise kisi anya mutual fund mein — ek tay schedule par ek tay amount invest ki jaati hai, us din ke NAV par process hokar. Kisi schedule par ETF mein ek tay amount invest karna bhi sambhav hai, lekin iska matlab hai har baar kisi broker ke zariye, us pal jo bhi price market de raha ho, us par exchange par trade karna — mutual fund SIP se alag mechanical process, bhale hi underlying investment objective milta-julta ho.

Koi bhi structure underlying market risk nahi badalta. Aap inmein se jiski bhi tulna kar rahe hon, product abhi bhi kisi market index ko track karta hai — ya track karne ka lakshya rakhta hai — aur iski value us market ke saath badh ya gir sakti hai, chaahe aap ise kaise bhi khareedein ya bechein.

Mukhya baatein

  • Index fund aur ETF ek jaisa index track kar sakte hain — inke beech fark structural hai, is baat mein nahi ki ye kya karne ki koshish kar rahe hain.
  • Index fund seedhe fund se din ke end ke NAV par khareeda aur redeem kiya jaata hai; ETF poore din exchange par market price par trade hota hai.
  • ETF ke liye demat aur trading account chahiye, bilkul share khareedne jaisa; index fund ke liye nahi.
  • ETF ki market price uske apne NAV se alag ho sakti hai — premium ya discount par trade karte hue — jo index fund ke tracking difference se alag baat hai.
  • Brokerage aur exchange ka bid-ask spread ETF-specific costs hain, jo index fund ki seedhi khareed mein usi tarah nahi aatin.
  • Index fund mein SIP ek standard mutual fund SIP hai; ETF mein schedule par ek tay amount invest karne ka matlab hai har baar exchange par trade karna.

Apne numbers par aazmaiye

Aksar pooche jaane wale sawaal

Sources aur editorial review

Aage kya padhein

Index Fund Kya Hota Hai?Index fund kya hota hai, ye kisi market index ko track karne ki koshish kaise karta hai, ye active management se kaise alag hai, aur tracking difference aur tracking error asal mein kya measure karte hain.Mutual Fund Mein NAV Kya Hai?Net Asset Value ka matlab kya hai, yeh kaise nikala aur declare hota hai, kam NAV se fund sasta kyun nahi ho jaata, aur aapke transaction par kaun-sa NAV lagu hota hai.Mutual Fund Ka Expense Ratio Kya Hai?Total Expense Ratio kya cover karta hai, yeh aapse bill kiye jaane ke bajaye NAV ke andar kaise liya jaata hai, yeh lambi holding period mein kaise compound hota hai, aur iski sahi tulna kaise karein.Mutual Fund Kya Hai Aur Yeh Kaise Kaam Karta Hai?Indian mutual funds mein pooling, units, NAV, fund categories, cost aur market risk ka seedhi bhasha mein introduction.

Sirf educational content. Investment advice nahi.

Risk Factors – Investments in Mutual Funds are subject to Market Risks. Read all scheme-related documents carefully before investing. Mutual Fund Schemes do not assure or guarantee any returns. Past performance of any Mutual Fund Scheme may or may not be sustained in the future. There is no guarantee that the investment objective of any suggested scheme will be achieved. All existing and prospective investors are advised to check and evaluate the exit loads and other cost structure (TER) applicable at the time of making an investment before finalizing any investment decision for Mutual Fund Schemes. We deal in Regular Plans only for Mutual Fund Schemes and earn a trailing commission on client investments. Disclosure of commission earnings is made to clients at the time of investment. The option of a Direct Plan for every Mutual Fund Scheme is available to investors and offers the advantage of a lower expense ratio. We are not entitled to earn any commission on Direct Plans; hence, we do not deal in Direct Plans.